I now have this pesky, buggy issue too. It definitely seems to have started after I went to ebay, although I suppose it could have happened at any website. I first saw it when trying to navigate to ESPN.com yesterday. As soon as ESPN loaded, the popup certificate warning came up: "Safari can't verify the identity of the website tags.bluekai.com. The certificate for this website is invalid. You might be connecting to a website that is pretending to be tags.bluekai.com, which could put your confidential information at risk. Would you like to connect to the website anyway?" Crazy. I'm at Espn.com not bluekai. So it wants to redirect...I guess? Not sure because I simply leave ESPN when it happens.
I spent the better part of yesterday attempting to fix this. Read a lot. I'm unable to find a working solution aside from "use Firefox." True. It doesn't happen on Firefox but Firefox upgrades their browser and Apple no longer updates Safari for older systems. I prefer Safari as my default browser and I find it hard to comprehend -- no one has figured out a fix.
Yes, I have tried everything suggested on the Apple forums and other trustworthy sites. Nothing has succeeded in making this 'bluekai certificate warning' go away.
What I am also seeing is this issue had a lot of traction in early-mid February 2018. After late February, I don't see additional reports or complaints. That leads me to thinking there IS a solution and I have not located it.
I also noticed if I disable Java from Safari, the tags.bluekai.com certificate popup disappears. (Is this thing even considered a "popup?) However, once I disable Java, I cannot see the content at Espn.com so certainly not a fix but makes me wonder about Java issues. Why is any site still using Java? Rhetorical question.
Machine specs: MBP 17" 2011
1TB SSD/2.8GHz Intel Core i7/8 GB RAM
OSX 10.9.5/Safari v.9.1.3
Other: No virus or adblocking software installed on machine
** I don't want to turn this into an off topic discussion about those of us who LOVE our 17" MBPs and why we are unwilling to upgrade to High Sierra. Suffice it to say, as long as I can keep this machine going, I need it for work purposes. I don't want to install High Sierra unless/until Apple makes another 17" laptop...which I realize probably won't happen. There are a lot of us who are hoarding and protecting these "vintage" machines because there are no alternatives on the market. Just trying to explain why the simple solution of "upgrading the OS" isn't viable to a certain population of Mac users. Truly don't want/need to get into an off topic discussion of pros/cons of newer machines.
I also ran the Etre check. Didn't want to create an even longer post if there is a simple fix I am not seeing. I'd happily post the results if anyone thinks that would be helpful. Or -- if there is anything else I can tell you about the computer or pesky bluekai issue, ask away and I'll answer. I'm certainly no programmer but do know my way around Macs. I've been using them for 25+ years.
Thanks, all. Appreciate any help or suggestions, in advance.