Repeated logic board failures on 2018 MacBook Pro

I am faced with repairing an out of warranty 2018 MacBook Pro with a Mac Service Center diagnosed logic board failure. My concern is will the new board eventually fail or since this has been reported to be a problem with this model can I expect the new board is more durable. Does anybody else have experience with this. My option is of course to repair it, almost a $600 repair, or buy a new Mac. I have not given up on Macs I have owned three MacBook Pros over the last 15 years and they until now been very reliable.

Posted on Jul 16, 2020 6:29 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 18, 2021 7:54 AM

Just buy a new one. I’m now out 1400 dollars because my 2018 MacBook Pro logic board failed in September 2019 (two weeks out of year warranty and Apple refused to cover it). Now in January 2021 my logic board again is broken and my computer suddenly isn’t turning on (was working fine yesterday). Not sure how it isn’t being considered a part of the recall given the same part has been replaced thrice in a 3 year period.

65 replies

Aug 30, 2020 10:25 AM in response to SolarPawa

I agree and if you do a search for logic board failures specific to this model you will be shocked at the number that come up. I have still not decided what to do. I’m afraid of replacing the board only to spend the money and have it fail again. I was told by another forum member the board that would be used to replace it would be the same as the original which to me means just as likely to fail. In my opinion why there is not more of an uproar about this is perhaps many were under extended Apple Care.

Aug 30, 2020 6:10 PM in response to Gregg Gandy

You are probably right about the extended Apple Care. I did not get one. I have another Macbook Pro (an one year earlier model) that exhibited a stage light effect on the bottom of the screen after one year and 5 months. When I took it to Apple, they said the whole screen and top lid had to be replaced for a hefty sum. I did not have the budget for it but eventually, they issued a recall because they got more and more of the same complaint. I am hoping this happens with our Macbook Pro. It has already happened with the logic boards of Macbook Air

Sep 17, 2020 10:14 AM in response to LokeshVattikuti

The problem that I think you are stating and is the same I am concerned about is if I spend the money to replace the logic board will the replacement last. It would certainly be less expensive than buying a new MacBook Pro. Unfortunately someone replied earlier in this or another thread that the replacement would be the "same" logic board and as such just as likely to fail. Personally I do not like those odds. I mean if they could just say here is the cause for the failure and we have a fix then that would be great. I went back and found the YouTube video where a tech goes step by step through a repair of a MacBook logic board. My theory and it is just a theory is that there is a particular small part or connection that with this particular design is a weak link that has been failing. It is a long video but if you are curious about what may have been the fault it is worth the time. While I was searching for this I could not believe the number of advertisements for companies offering logic board repair and replacements for MacBook Pros.

Sep 17, 2020 6:27 PM in response to Gregg Gandy

Apple DOES investigate the reasons for failures that end up back at their depots for repair. When failures seem high, they spare no expense to find the reasons behind the failures, including examining every component, sometimes with a strong microscope peering inside chips and sawing boards in half to look at board construction and solder joints.


When their analysis are complete, they sometimes issue a recall. Because they know exactly which failures and exactly what the causes were, and exactly which Macs built during which weeks were affected, they will sometimes include the ones built the week BEFORE yours was built. This can be extremely frustrating, but it says that although there was a problem it did not apply to your specific Mac, and if you have a failure that seems the same, yours is down to bad luck, not the well-researched defect.

Jan 10, 2021 7:47 AM in response to wlphk

My 2018 MacPro 13” just stopped working few days ago, when I took it to a repairshop, I was told the motherboard was fried out of the blue. No water spills, drops or powers surges in my area that would have caused the issue. The computer is just only 26 months, unfortunately out of warranty, but it is incredible how unreliable these newer models have turned out. Due to work, I had to immediately replace it with a 2020MBAIr, which I am starting to be concerned, if I will give up after 2 years of use. I still have a 2012 MacbookPro and it is still running, and that one did have a logic board replacement.

Jan 12, 2021 7:00 AM in response to Gregg Gandy

I am genuinely sorry you have had such Bad Luck. There is nothing Readers can do to repair your confidence in the product except to assure you that your single sample does NOT represent a TREND.


Apple made around 20 million Macs last year, and your bad experience with a sample of one does not move the needle on reliability in the slightest. It is not statistically significant.


When Consumer Reports magazine polls their members in their annual survey, Apple computers and Apple service have been the highest rated (compared to any other company) for many years running.

Jan 31, 2021 8:50 AM in response to jantacor

I did not repair my 2018 but have fallen back to my 2015 which is still working without any failures. Someone responded that we that are having problems are such a small minority that it is not a real problem.


I guess you can take that opinion many ways. Unfortunately I took it to mean we are not large enough to be a financial concern that the loss of our business and purchase of Apple products worth addressing. My Quadra 700 purchase in 1991 through so many more desktop, mobile, accessory and phone Apple purchases are not even as much as an atom in Apple’s business universe.

Mar 8, 2021 7:35 PM in response to Gregg Gandy

I experienced this also with my 2018 MBP. It just won't turn on anymore. Mac Service Center diagnosed it as a logic board failure and it costs me PHP45,000 to repair/replace. It's very disappointing because I was only able to use it for a year and a half. Hope this gets to Apple. I know a lot of people here in the Philippines who experienced the same problem and we think it's a bit unfair. This laptop is so expensive.

Mar 10, 2021 10:58 AM in response to Loby

@Loby,

Thank you for your responses and support to those following this thread. Personally I believe it is always helpful for others to know they are not alone with a problem with or without support from the manufacturer. I am in a service position myself and have had experiences with distributors and manufacturers who when confronted with a product failure have told me that we(our company) are the only ones having this problem. More than once I have learned later sometimes a couple of years that it was a widespread problem. This is getting off topic but in one case I happened to call a company and the manager was out so the parts manager answered my call. When I asked if we could get a new part he said he was unsure because they had a huge backlog because he was doing all he could to fulfill warranty replacements. This was for a part I was told we were the only one having the problem. So I am sensitive to this.


I think that was good advice and everyone following should keep all their records just in case this is resolved or some help from Apple is offered.

Mar 13, 2021 2:06 PM in response to Gregg Gandy

My MBP 15" Touch Bar 2018 has the same problem. Working one day, I leave it in the sleep mode, in the next day it didn't turn on, no charge, nothing.


I took it to third-party assistance, since the Apple Store is closed due to the COVID pandemic. They diagnosed a failure of the logic board and the same was replaced with the touch ID, all for Apple Care. Zero cost.


I am afraid because the replaced board is the same, and there is no feedback to correct the problem. Just as you think that the entire new Macbook line, since 2017, may have this problem.


Apple Care ends next year, what to do? That is the question.

Apr 10, 2021 8:29 PM in response to micoy16

I’m from Mexico.

Download the support app, there all your apple products will appear.

Start a ticket & ask to be contacted, they will call you

Apple made sure my MacBook showed no damage with the service shop.

After two days they called me back to let me know Apple was taking care

What model is yours? What year? Is it also the logic board?

Best of luck

Apr 11, 2021 3:26 AM in response to domvera

It's sad that only a few of us got the chance to have it repaired for FREE even if it's out of warranty. Apple just gave my MBP a week ago and only gave me three months for the warranty, which I believe is too short.


Anyway, I emailed them several times and messaged them, asking what caused the logic board to fail so early. NO ONE GAVE ME AN ANSWER. They are all quiet on the issue and are playing it safe.


I'm grateful for the free logic board but I still STRONGLY BELIEVE that they should issue a recall program, just to be fair for everyone. This machine is so EXPENSIVE only to have a lifespan of 2 years. Note that I never dropped it nor dropped any liquid on it.


All my files were lost, including my clients', during the repair because they had to format it before repairing it. It's just UNBELIEVABLE.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Repeated logic board failures on 2018 MacBook Pro

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.