Ok, here’s some more strange behaviour:
…read an old post somewhere about downloading a purchased tune that was not held locally resolving some past ‘sync’ issues (not specifically the one we’re all currently complaining about)…
So I know I’ve deleted some purchased tracks because I’d since bought the CD and wanted to RIP @ ALAC quality… so went into iTunes Store/Purchased/Not In My Library and re-downloaded a few tracks…
They show in my Library (as iCloud Status: Waiting - never paid much attention previously, but why ‘waiting’ when iTunes downloaded this as a previous purchase?).
These re-downloaded songs are local on my MBP (used ‘show in finder’).
Also very surprised to see two of the purchased songs showing as ‘128 kbps’ rather than the standard 256 kbps that’s standard with iTunes Store purchases (2 other past purchases re-downloaded came in as 256kbps).
The 128kbps files show as kind: ‘Protected AAC audio file’ and have a blue dotted cloud icon (I thought we got Purchased rather than Protected when Apple removed DRM for music?). The 256 Kbps files show as ‘Purchased AAC audio file’; while also showing ‘Waiting’ these don’t have the blue dotted icon.
From my perspective, it looks like the iTunes Store catalogue is very screwy! IF that is widespread, then no wonder Match is struggling.
While I did all this, I’d already set another Library sync in progress (no positive outcome of course). I then cancelled and restarted the library sync. Two of the re-downloaded songs I’d managed to download twice (was that my fault, or something iTunes shouldn’t have allowed to happen?). On the attempted resync, nothing had changed in terms of waiting, except one of the duplicate pairs (not both) changed one of the songs from Waiting to Duplicate and from Protected to ‘MPEG-4 audio file’ - none of this is consistent or logical, IMO.
Anyway, while the exercise demonstrated that it’s still possible to download through iTunes (though can’t speak for new purchases, only re-downloading previous purchases), it hasn’t resolved the Match issue.