macOS Ventura Apple Mail messages are blank / empty

This seems to be an intermittent yet long-lived bug i.e. it keeps coming up version after version. This is currently happening to me on Ventura 13.0.1 and Apple Mail 16.0. I do not see any pending updates. I am not running antivirus or vpn software.


I have done the following:

• turned off all checkboxes on the Preferences > Privacy pane; restarted Mail.

• opened the email in its own window.

• rebuilt the inbox (select inbox, click Mailbox > Rebuild); restarted Mail.


Still can't see the email.


I can see the message body if:

• I open the email in icloud.com

• I forward the email in the desktop client


Things I have not tried yet:

• safe boot

• resetting Apple mail preferences


Reference posts are below; only in one of them has the poster reported back that they got it working (they were running anti-virus software (Avast) but that doesn't apply to me).


Email body not visible on Apple Mail Clie… - Apple Community

https://www.sanebox.com/help/29-apple-mail-emails-are-appearing-blank

Body of email messages appears blank - Apple Community

OS12 Mail message content is blank - Apple Community

Emails in Apple Mail just went blank - Apple Community

Blank Mail body - Apple Community

Email Contents Blank Since Upgrading To M… - Apple Community

icloud mail content invisible in 12.0.1 - Apple Community

Mac mail messages appear blank - Apple Community

Blank email body - Apple Community

Mail Not Working on Your Mac? Here’s How to Fix Any Apple Mail Problem










MacBook Pro 16″, macOS 13.0

Posted on Dec 19, 2022 9:58 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 20, 2023 12:58 PM

After reading and testing some possible solutions - including switching to outlook - I seem to have fixed the issue (for now). I exported all my local inboxes to mbox, deleted completely the ~/Library/Mail folder, then went to the web-version of my work email and gmail, deleted as many as possible email (went from some 70k back to ~6k emails, including sent email copies) and then opened Mail again. It downloaded everything from the servers and then I added back my local mailboxes where I archive my mail, importing back the mboxes.

I haven't run into blank emails yet and also have only sporadically the stuck "Downloading messages" notice.

Before this solution I tried rebuilding the mailbox and lost several emails, so I do not recommend that.

Whether this is a general solution, I really do not know. It does seem that a corrupt mail screwed up Mail's indexing, like in the post below, but I could not find out which email, so I tried this more rigorous solution. My problem may in part also be due to large number mails that were in all mailboxes, but still I would expect Apple Mail to be able to deal with that.

Similar questions

51 replies

Oct 6, 2023 10:34 AM in response to martin draax

Further information:

The update to Sonoma did not resolve this. In fact the Mail and Safari problems got worse after the update, as did a number of other issues which I had been experiencing.

I had previously been advised by Apple Support to carry out an Erase and Install but this did not resolve the problems.

I have been to the Genius Bar today and they have completely reformatted my Mac.

The Genius carried out a lot of tests but no problems were found with the hardware. He said he thought the problems might have been caused by restoring from Time Machine. I'm not convinced but we'll see. I have manually copied the files I need back to the machine and installed only the Apple iWork Apps. I will give it a day or so to see what happens. All the nonsense with the machine and now a second Erase and Install has wasted a great deal of my time. I will not be very patient with my next contact with Apple Support should that be necessary . . .

John

Jan 9, 2023 11:47 AM in response to aangel

I have the exact same issue: some email only show the subject line while the body is blank. I never had it before, started after upgrade to Ventura, now after updating to 13.1 the issue is still there.

There seems to be a relation to moving messages from inbox to another mailbox, as all my messages that are automatically moved to a separate folder using a rule show up blank. Messages in the main inbox are fine, except when I move them to local mailbox, then some become blank as well. This is also happens when I moved message from the Junk folder back to to the inbox.... This is all using a corporate Exchange email account and Apple Mail as my long-time favourite mail app.

How to fix this??

Mar 18, 2023 2:04 PM in response to tbirdvet

Update. I had the "show remote images" set to off in Outlook which is why I thought it had no/little content. I reinstalled MS Outlook and no issue with the mail content. I tested Outlook side by side with Apple Mail and when I got an email with no content on Apple Mail it showed full content in MS Outlook. I guess I can assume this is an Apple mail issue only. I may stay with outlook unless Apple can fix this issue.

May 1, 2023 5:02 AM in response to aangel

I also have this problem. It started with Ventura. I run the latest version (13.3.1). I can add the following:

  • It also occurs often that the content pane of the message turns all black instead of all white (thus, is still unreadable).
  • Same thing happens in Safari. Someone mentioned that it has to do with the rendering toolkit that Safari and Apple Mail share, and if you don't open Safari, it won't happen in Apple Mail. But for me, not running Safari only helped initially. I now do get white or black content panes in Apple Mail, without Safari having ever been opened.
  • What I also noticed is that in some dialog boxes, not all buttons appear; some are all white, in particular the save button when adding an email attachment (see screenshot; next to the Cancel button there is an invisible but operational Save button!).


Any help would be highly appreciated, because this interferes heavily with my daily workflow (in other words, it is driving me crazy).

Nov 9, 2023 1:22 AM in response to suewestlake

I tried the option in OnyX --> Maintenance --> Mailboxes in Mail --> Rebuild the index

but it didn't work for me.

All other options were left at the default settings:

Verifying, both turned on;

Rebuilding --> Launch Services database, turned on;

Cleaning, all four options turned on.

I've had the problem with some blank emails, especially those with images, for six or nine months now! Choosing to Forward an email usually loads the entire message but it's ****** annoying and shameful Apple's let it go on for so long...

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

macOS Ventura Apple Mail messages are blank / empty

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.