Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

I have been using my iPhone 8 for a little over 6 weeks. Last night I plugged in my phone to charge and walked away for about an hour. When I came back the phone had turned off and I observed a hairline crack running across the home button. The phone was not dropped or even touched during this time. It honestly just spontaneously cracked. I know that the iPhone 7 had a similar issue but I was not able to find anyone that had experiences a similar issue with the iPhone 8.

I called Apple care and they advised that it would be anywhere from 99-600 dollars to have the home button replaced. Has anyone had a similar issue with their iPhone 8 or 8 plus? Thank you.

Posted on Nov 9, 2017 1:29 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on May 28, 2018 8:04 PM

Here you go, I have changed some details but you get the jist. Also I cant share the email address as it pertains to my particular Apple case ID and mine has been closed. You will need to reply to the email you receive from the Apple rep.I hope this helps your case and I hope this gets more traction to get the wider issue looked at.

Hi,
Firstly, thank you for your great customer service and support yesterday and making an
exception to fix my iPhone 8 + screen due to the home button cracking itself.
However, this is not the end of the issue and I will list them below;


  • I went to Oobe in Wellington NZ yesterday and the guy advised based on the notes that Apple will fix the screen (home button included) free of charge however any other damage resulting from this issue they will not cover.
  • He asked me to wipe my phone but back it up first at home – I tried to update it then back it up but the phone, either hardware or software, has corrupted terribly and now it has been restored to factory with several issues to me personally.
    1. I lost ALL my data as it would not update and self-restored to factory settings – I had a lot of baby photos from January (we had a newborn on Jan 3rd) and I hadn’t backed up my phone as we moved into my in-laws house while we
      build our house so my computer is in storage making it difficult to do my once a month back up to my PC. I also had some personal notes not backed up anywhere which is also painful. I never thought my 7 month old phone would break so quickly.
    2. The phone after restoring still will not boot up to the hello screen or anything else so I used an existing back up to restore to the phone and that did not work so it keeps looping through apple logo, bar loading and then black screen which suggest it could be something more than just the screen itself, it could be a hardware or software issue that you advised would not be covered as only
      the screen replacement is covered by Apple.
  • I have logged a claim with my insurance company as I think this will not be resolved as easily as I think and this will cost me $200 excess as well as a penalty on my non-claims bonus. This is pending and I haven’t undertaken this course of action yet but the claim is lodged.
  • I did some further research on this issue and found many threads that replicate exactly what happened to me and my device. Reading the comments reiterated to me that I did not drop or bang my phone but this happened on its own via some faulty hardware or just pure bad design. Below are the threads I have looked at and most come from the Apple community forums on the Apple website. I will
    restate; I did not drop the phone, I did not bump it against anything, I did not handle it roughly prior to the damage and I never have. I had used it with no issues, then 5 mins later charged it, then not long after I pulled out the lightning cable and placed into my pocket but had not checked the phone so it could have been damaged by then. I went to the bathroom and kitchen and after 5 mins I went to my desk pulled it out of my pocket and saw the damage. It sits in a Otterbox symmetry case with a screen protector on it – it is cared for as if it is one of my children and cost me $1449 NZD which I still have not fully paid for yet.
  • Here are the threads I mentioned and they all have a common theme – they were charging it and came back to see damage. Could it be that the charging is causing this issue:
    1. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8153835 - my phone looks exactly as the picture in this thread
    2. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8269914
    3. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8308437
    4. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8250804 - this is exactly my issue
    5. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8069340 - subject line refers to iPhone 7 but some comments mention iPhone 8
    6. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7742979 - also iphone 7 related but they use the same/similar hardware for the home
      button
    7. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8093709
    8. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8046417
There are many more of these re iPhone 7 on Apple’s website and from other websites but I think you get the point.
Im very frustrated that I can easily see a common theme here but Apple doesn’t – I have wasted time, energy and money on this issue and Apple hasn’t accepted liability they have only just made an “exception” for me where I see a bigger issue.
I am tempted to go to my commerce commission, Fair Go (NZ TV show that deals with consumers being ripped off) and our media outlets to vent my frustration and make this known to the wider community.
My main concern is that this may happen to other people and they go through the same process as me and get frustrated and potentially lose all their data (like I did which is causing me a massive headache and my new-borns pictures from his birth cannot be recovered ).
This shouldn’t happen and the response from Apple’s reps is unacceptable.
I will await your response before proceeding with what action I will take.
Please reply as quickly as you can as I need to make a decision soon.
Thanks.
255 replies

Feb 11, 2018 3:24 PM in response to honoluluhandy

Same thing happened to me. Less than 30 days old. No damage. Woke up in the morning to a cracked home button while charging on my desk. No other physical damage. Like others, apple genius tech denied ever hearing about it. I showed him this thread and the members pictures. He logged the issue and my complaint. $199 CDN and a new screen later I have my phone back. Disappointed to say the least.

Feb 13, 2018 3:29 PM in response to Emcampb2

@applesupport there are many complaints about the home button on the iPhone 8 plus being cracked/broken on its own. We are all hoping there is a solution to have this problem resolved without having to go to an outside repair shop and spend extra money for something that is obviously a factory defect. it would be nice if apple can look further into this for many of us experiencing this sad situation. I don't know who would want to break their brand new phone. Please help us all.

Feb 15, 2018 1:36 AM in response to Emcampb2

It is 2 months old phone which was never been dropped and has in the shockproof case & NUglass protector. 3 days ago in the morning, My phone's display became black and unresponsive. I took it to Apple store today. After some diagnostics, They said the display needs to be changed. The Apple personnel took it inside for test then returned back after few minutes. He showed me that the phone is discoverable on iTunes in their computer. I said that I noticed the same with my computer's iTunes, but couldn't connect because I can't unlock it due to touch screen was also not working. Then he looked at it and said it is broken.


Which is completely surprising. How could a home button break without being dropped? He said that some heavy thing might fall on it and cause the damage. They quote $220 AUD for fixing it which I can't afford the cost. I walk away from the store and will wait until I able to manage that money.


A totally disappointing experience I'm having with such expensive product.

Feb 19, 2018 10:05 AM in response to Emcampb2

Mine just popped last night. Not dropped and nothing fell on it, laying on my desk charging at the firehouse. On its way to get looked at right now. Wish I had taken a picture because my crack is the exact same as the picture posted on here earlier just turned a different direction, little triangle and everything. Lets hope something is done. Its also stuck on the boot screen and thats all the farther it will go but it will be recognized by the computer for an update or restore, just cant use my screen to acknowledge it since its froze and keeps boot cycling. Come on @applesupport, lets get this fixed please!!

Feb 19, 2018 6:03 PM in response to Emcampb2

I had my Iphone 8 plus for 4 months now and it had been working fine. Last week I pulled my phone out of my pocket and saw the Apple logo and figured my phone was just restarting. After the several hours of the logo remaining on the screen I contacted support and tried to fix the issue. Nothing worked. The next day I noticed noticed a hairline crack across the home button. I didn't understand because I did not drop the phone or do anything to make that damage occur. I then realized that the rebooting of the phone happened because of the cracked home button. I have not had problems like this with Apple in the past, but I was very disappointed with this because I didn't do anything to make the damage occur. I had to get a whole new phone which was expensive. Apple please look into this issue!!

Mar 3, 2018 3:16 AM in response to Emcampb2

Just woke up with this issue. I am responding from my older iPad Air

. I’ve only had my iPhone 8 for a couple of months. Last night put my phone on the charger. Woke up to a completely dead phone And the home button could not be pushed so I am assuming it’s cracked or busted Jin some way. As much as we pay for these phones you would think they would be made tougher. I haven’t dropped it. I have taken very good care of it. I only use it around the house I never go anywhere. It’s crazy, at this rate I’ll go through about 20 of them.This is ridiculous!

Mar 6, 2018 4:21 AM in response to tymcgon

yes! I had the same issue one day. I was listening to a podcast with headphones on and the phone in my pocket and it stopped suddenly. I payed it no mind but later when I looked at my phone it was on the restart screen and kept rebooting with the apple logo for HOURS. When I managed to wipe it clean (plugged into my mac) I realized my home button was shattered! And without that button, you can't restart your phone from scratch (setting up language/Siri/etc)


My phone was in an otterbox case with a tempered glass covering the screen. I never had this issue with the 4, 5, or 6. ONLY MY 8 PLUS! It gets better... After using my carriers insurance and paying $120 (mind you I had the phone for only 2 weeks) I got a new phone and 2 months later, its happened again!!!!


I never drop my phone and never had this issue but it seems to be a reoccurring issue with this particular phone. They need to do something about this like they did with the "slowing the phones down" fiasco.

Mar 7, 2018 10:53 PM in response to Csound1

I wouldn’t go as far to say it’s a manufacturers defect but I experienced the same issue.... TWICE! There is something going on with these 8+ phones. I had the phone for 2 weeks, had to file a claim with my carrier and now the new one did the same thing. I believe it has something to do with the charging. It gets too hot and the home button cracks. It’s just a theory bc there’s no way I can think of a way to do research but there is definitely something going on

Mar 7, 2018 11:01 PM in response to nicoleiphone8plus

Hi I had the same issue with my iPhone 8plus. One day i looked at it and the home button was shattered in my pocket. I went thru my carriers insurance and got a new phone (ridiculous bc I had the phone for only 2 weeks) and 2 months later my new phone did the same thing! I called Apple and they said this isn’t a wide spread issue (supposedly) and I brought up these discussions on their website they said “it’s a forum where anyone can just write this”.


I have a theory that the charging port overheats and the button cracks since it’s rigjt next to the charging port. There needs to be more complaints from customers like us that pay nearly $1,000 for a phone and it can’t wven handle its own charging port.

Mar 10, 2018 7:06 AM in response to chrisfrombaldwin

chrisfrombaldwin wrote:


Hi I had the same issue with my iPhone 8plus. One day i looked at it and the home button was shattered in my pocket. I went thru my carriers insurance and got a new phone (ridiculous bc I had the phone for only 2 weeks) and 2 months later my new phone did the same thing! I called Apple and they said this isn’t a wide spread issue (supposedly) and I brought up these discussions on their website they said “it’s a forum where anyone can just write this”.


Basically the issue is out of millions of iPhone 8s in the public a very small number are experiencing this, though it certainly is horrible if it happens to you.


As I've mentioned before, the only way to do anything about it is to make sure you take your phone in for replacement; Apple certainly can and does notice ongoing issues in their products in that manner.


Recall we're just users here so there could be 10,000 reports of the same thing posted here but this forum isn't how issues like this one gain attention among the engineers who could examine it.

Mar 19, 2018 6:39 PM in response to Dogcow-Moof

So, this happened to me too, and as you suggest, I took it in to apple....I was chatting good night with my daughter who was lying in her bed, phone in her hand (I caught her still, up, texting...) and while I was talking to her, her iPhone 8 died as in the screen went blank. Then as none of the buttons were working, she handed it to me. We turn on the light and her home button was cracked. There is NO way she wouldn't have noticed this earlier on her "precious" and she did not drop the phone in the last two months (brand new in December, and yes she did damage the glass screen saver one time in the first week she had it). Even if she had, it was in a case, with a protruding front lip. You'd have to hit this with a nail and hammer to get a crack right on the home button....

So, I found out we have a $150 deductible with the carrier's insurance. So then I chatted with an apple agent for 96 minutes, rebooting (unsuccessful) and then restoring the phone to discover, of course, that the home button didn't work. So then we went to the store. They went through the same process, and then insisted that she must have dropped it or it wouldn't have cracked. I agree it is hard to believe, but I was there.... she didn't cause this! They apparently think we are lying. So, $169 later (they told me $149, but of course then you pay tax too, which was left off the discussion...), another hour and half (took longer than they said to fix, which also makes me wonder), she has functioning phone again, but I have had it with apple. I have had all apple stuff for years and happily bought an 8 plus when we got her the 8, but I will not be buying any more apple gear, and now I am just waiting for my home button to crack too.... Last night, I had read some of the posts on this website. How could all these people have spontaneously cracking home buttons on their iPhone 8s without there being some fault with the phone? I am really, really disappointed.... and angry that I have wasted all of my day off plus a substantial sum to get it working again. What choice do you have at that point?

I welcome a response from Apple, and I'll be waiting for them to own up to this fault and issue a refund, but I don't know how they can win back my enthusiasm.

Mar 19, 2018 9:50 PM in response to alexandrafromoberlin

I’m my first situation, it occurred at work: I’m not sure if I was charging my phone before it happened BUT in my second breakage, it happened immediately after I got out my car from charging my phone. I saw someone else had it happen to them while they were charging their phone. My question to you, was your daughter charging her phone when it happened?


I have a strong feeling the charging port overheats and since the home button is right there, the glass breaks. Apple suggests that people on this forum “could be just anyone writing anything with no proof” *exact words told to me over the phone*. They also said if it was noted like the whole “Slowing the iPhone 6 down” fiasco, then Apple would be proactive in helping us out.

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.